Striking a Balance between the Execution of Sentence and Pardon Implementation in Nigeria: A Way Forward
Abstract
This paper aims to find a middle ground between sentencing and pardoning as procedures within Nigeria’s criminal justice system to enhance justice. As a contribution to the growing body of work challenging the perceived and actual disparities and increasing public outrage over recent high-profile pardons, this paper examines the historical precedent for tension between sentencing and executive pardon. Through a doctrinal research methodology, this paper discusses the Nigerian legal regimes on sentencing and pardoning and their major inconsistencies and absence of clear guidelines. Key findings in this paper suggest that the absence of adequate and transparent procedures in the matters of sentencing and pardoning results in whimsical decisions that are capable of undermining the credibility of the judiciary. The implications of this study are important for both the judicial and executive authorities, promoting changes to practices of both sentencing and pardoning so that they are dispensed fairly and equitably. This paper adds new knowledge to the current discourse on the need to achieve an equilibrium that can preserve judicial independence while making room for executive interference where necessary in the Nigerian criminal justice system.
References
Abdullahi, I. (2022). Presidential Pardon Granted to Nigeria’s Rev. Jolly Nyame, Joshua Dariye and 157 Others: Delimiting the Confluence Between Morality and Legality. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 9(6), 58–67.
Adeniji v. State, 645 NWLR 356 (Supreme Court of Nigeria 2000).
Akinyemi v. State, 6 NWLR 465 (Supreme Court of Nigeria 1999).
Amnesty International. (6 July, 2006). Japan: ‘Will this day be my last?’ The death penalty in Japan. Amnesty International, 28
Attorney General, Federation v. Abubakar, 10 NWLR 1 (Supreme Court of Nigeria 2007).
Badejogbin, O. (2018). Onuoha Kalu v The State and flaws in Nigeria’s death penalty jurisprudence. African Human Rights Law Journal, 18(2), 551–578.
Bamigbola, B. (23 September, 2024). Osun aluminum worker jailed six months for stealing yam. Punch Newspapers. https://punchng.com/osun-aluminum-worker-jailed-six-months-for-stealing-yam/.
Campagna, G. (2021). The Miracle of Mercy. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 41(4), 1096–1118.
Cocks, T. (13 March, 2013). Nigeria president pardons ex-governor convicted of graft. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/world/nigeria-president-pardons-ex-governor-convicted-of-graft-idUSBRE92C0WK/.
Foster, M. A. (2020). Presidential Pardons: Overview and Selected Legal Issues (R46179; pp. 1–24). Congressional Research Service. https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R46179.
Fox, R. G. (1999). When Justice Sheds a Tear: The Place of Mercy in Sentencing. Monash University Law Review, 1–28.
Habib, G. (2024, October 26). 12 govs pardon 1,780 inmates to decongest prisons. Punch Newspapers. https://punchng.com/12-govs-pardon-1780-inmates-to-decongest-prisons/.
Harvard Law Review. (2021). The President’s Conditional Pardon Power. Harvard Law Review, 138(8), 2833–2854.
Human Rights Watch. (2004). “Political Shari’a”?: Human Rights and Islamic Law in Northern Nigeria (Country Reports A1609). Human Rights Watch. https://www.refworld.org/reference/countryrep/hrw/2004/en/19627.
Ige, I. O. (18 August, 2022). Dariye & Nyame Pardon: Between legality and impunity. Vanguard News. https://www.vanguardngr.com/2022/08/dariye-nyame-pardon-between-legality-and-impunity/.
Ikpeze, O. V. C. & Ezeh, M. O. (2021). The Concept of Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice System in Nigeria. Journal Of International Human Rights And Contemporary Legal Issues, 1, Article 0.
Joseph Amoshima v. The State, 14 NWLR 1 (2014).
Kabo Air Ltd v. Mohammed, 5 NWLR 38 (Court of Appeal 2015).
Kareem, K. (6 may, 2022). Are Presidential Pardons Really Prerogatives of Mercy or Political Handouts in Nigeria’s 4th Republic? Dataphyte. https://www.dataphyte.com/latest-reports/governance/are-presidential-pardons-really-prerogatives-of-mercy-or-political-handouts-in-nigerias-4th-republic/.
Major Hamza Al-Mustapha v. The State, 35840 JELR ___ (Court of Appeal 2013).
Mohammed v. Olawunmi, 2 NWLR 458 (Supreme Court of Nigeria 1992).
Muntari, T., Charles, J., & Ede, R. (2024, January 23). Kidnapping epidemic: Kano, nine others mull death sentence, life jail. Punch Newspapers. https://punchng.com/kidnapping-epidemic-kano-nine-others-mull-death-sentence-life-jail/.
National Constitution Center. (8 September, 2024). The Nixon pardon in constitutional retrospect. National Constitution Center – Constitutioncenter.org. https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/the-nixon-pardon-in-retrospect.
Ngwoke, R. A. & Abayomi, S. B. (2022). An Appraisal of the Power of Pardon under Nigerian Law: Lessons from Other Jurisdictions. Beijing Law Review, 13(2), Article 2.
Obadare, E. (18 April, 2022). State Pardon for Former Governors Puts Nigeria’s Anticorruption Drive in Jeopardy. Council on Foreign Relations. https://www.cfr.org/blog/state-pardon-former-governors-puts-nigerias-anticorruption-drive-jeopardy.
Office of the Pardon Attorney. (12 January, 2015). Office of the Pardon Attorney. https://www.justice.gov/pardon/about-office.
Okocha, C. (18 April, 2022). Transparency International, Others Condemn Pardon of Convicted Corrupt Politicians. This day Newspapers Ltd. https://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2022/04/18/transparency-international-others-condemn-pardon-of-convicted-corrupt-politicians/#google_vignette.
Okoro v. State, 14 NWLR 584 (Supreme Court of Nigeria 1998).
Onuoha Kalu v The State, 40 All N.L.R. ___ (Supreme Court of Nigeria 1998).
Ozekhome, M. (19 April, 2022). Legal and moral implications of granting pardons to (ex-)convicts. The Premium Times. https://www.premiumtimesng.com/opinion/524602-legal-and-moral-implications-of-granting-pardons-to-ex-convicts-by-mike-ozekhome.html?tztc=1.
Premium Times Nigeria. (29 August, 2024). Man jailed nine months for stealing two tubers of yam. Premium Times Nigeria. https://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/more-news/729122-man-jailed-nine-months-for-stealing-two-tubers-of-yam.html.
Punch Newspaper. (15 April, 2022). FG pardons ex-Govs Dariye, Nyame convicted for stealing N2.7bn. Punch Newspapers. https://punchng.com/fg-pardons-ex-govs-dariye-nyame-convicted-for-stealing-n2-7bn/.
Statista. (12 December, 2022). Nigeria: Number of death sentences 2010-2020. Statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1269977/number-of-death-sentences-in-nigeria/.
Statista. (4 July, 2024). Death sentences by country worldwide 2023. Statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/256459/number-of-death-sentences-worldwide/.
Sunday, O. (6 May, 2024). Two drivers jailed for violating traffic rules. Daily Post Nigeria. https://dailypost.ng/2024/05/06/two-drivers-jailed-for-violating-traffic-rules/.
Tanko v The State, 1–2 SC 198 (Supreme Court of Nigeria 2009).
The Governance of Britain. (2007). Review of the Executive Royal Prerogative Powers: Final Report (p. 36). Ministry of Justice. http://data.parliament.uk/DepositedPapers/Files/DEP2009-2493/DEP2009-2493.pdf.
Transparency International. (30 January, 2024). 2023 Corruption Perceptions Index: Explore the results. Transparency.org. https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2023.
Udofa, I. (2018). The Abuse of Presidential Power of Pardon and the Need for Restraints. Beijing Law Review, 9(2), Article 2.
Udombana, N. J. (2020). Administration of Criminal Justice Act of Nigeria 2015: A Critique of Selected Legislative Expressions. IALS Student Law Review, 7(2), 51–65.
Uduigwomen, A. F. (2005). A Critical Assessment Of The Retributive Theory Of Punishment. Global Journal of Humanities, 3(1), 9–13.
Umego, C. (2019). Offence of Kidnapping: A Counter to National Security and Development. SSRN Electronic Journal.
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2018). Introductory Handbook on The Prevention of Recidivism and the Social Reintegration of Offenders. United Nations. https://www.unodc.org/documents/justice-and-prison-reform/18-02303_ebook.pdf.
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (March, 2019). Crime Prevention & Criminal Justice Module 7 Key Issues: 2- Justifying punishment in the community. //www.unodc.org.
University of Minnesota. (2015). Criminal Law (01 ed.). University of Minnesota Libraries Publishing.
Watamura, E., Ioku, T., & Wakebe, T. (2022). Justification of Sentencing Decisions: Development of a Ratio-Based Measure Tested on Child Neglect Cases. Frontiers in Psychology, 12, Article 761536.
Whitehead, E. (11 August, 2015). Nigeria’s addiction to the death sentence. Al Jazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2015/8/11/nigerias-addiction-to-the-death-sentence.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Rita Abhavan Ngwoke, Tawakaltu Queen Oyinloye, Ugiomo Eruteya
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
The author fully assumes the content originality and the holograph signature makes him responsible in case of trial.
